Words actually fail me when it comes to the disaster (and that is the polite word for it!) that happened last week with the UK’s A Level results. We have all been waiting these long few months since lockdown started and school finished for Year 13s, it was ‘unprecedented’ a new and difficult situation but we put our faith in the government and the exam boards and hoped that they would do the right thing by a group of teenagers who had already been through enough.
Maybe we should have seen the writing on the wall?
Even during those first few weeks, decisions were made and changed, there was a great deal of uncertainty about how the system would work. Then we were told that data would be used; mock results, school data, teacher assessments. Then as the results date approached a new algorithm was announced. I think we should have realised then.
Although my own son is in Year 11, I have worked with Year 13 students this year, an amazing group of young people who inspired me with their work ethic and their aspirations to achieve great things. I wanted it to be alright for them but also for all of those students who had worked so hard.
But no, the system that we put our faith in has failed quite dismally for many students. Once again, teachers are made out to be the villains of the piece. They can’t be trusted to give realistic grades so the ‘algorithm’ kicked in to make everything fair. Fair? Is downgrading students by two grades fair? Is ensuring that lots of students don’t get into their chosen universities fair?
Is it fair that most of the teachers I know, spent hours carefully checking and rechecking their grades for both Year 11 and Year 13 students before submitting the grade. Those grades were then checked and double checked by heads of departments and senior leadership teams. All grades were within tolerance of the previous year to ensure that they couldn’t be accused of inflating grades. That in itself is unfair as every year is different. But I know the work that has gone into this and it isn’t a bunch of teachers rubbing their hands together with glee and plucking fantasy grades out of thin air to make their figures look better.
We don’t want students to be given inflated grades, they said. I get that, I do, but is that really the end of the world. A little pat on the shoulder of reassurance after a summer of crap. A summer where they were told that the following day would be the last day ever of their school education, no time for parties or goodbyes, no proms or celebrations, no summer of partying. A summer for most of them being stuck at home waiting.
What worries me more than anything is that the statistics show that mental health issues amongst teenagers in the UK is ever increasing and with the anxiety about COVID 19 and the impact of lockdown, we need to be building our teenager up, giving them hope, not tearing them down. They need something positive to help them move forward at this crucial time in their lives.
What we now need is clarity. We need to know what happens now. We need a fair system in place that helps all of those students to at least get a chance of achieving the grades they deserve. And we need it now, not in another few months time.
And for those students who didn’t achieve what they needed or wanted? No, it isn’t the end of the world, there are always other options and you aren’t defined by your grades. But I do feel your frustration and I understand that you want the grades you deserved.
I was looking forward to this Thursday when the GCSE grades are released. My son worked his socks off and deserved to do well. Whether he will or not, remains to be seen but if the GCSEs go the same way as the A Levels, I couldn’t even hazard a guess as to how he will do.
In my humble opinion, our teenagers have been through enough this year already and they could really do with some positivity in their lives. It needs sorting and soon.




They really have had enough this year. I really hoped they’d have trusted the teachers with their grades. I hope they fix it for those that need it. This will affect them for years to come xx
Susan Mann recently posted…School And A Plant Our Weekly Photos – Week 33
Amen to all of this! Very well put. I feel so sorry for the students and the teachers for all the hard work they’ve put in, only to have to go through the sh*t show of the last few days.
We will see what tomorrow brings with the GCSE results, but I’m not getting excited!
Sarah MumofThree World recently posted…Self-catering in Padstow during covid-19